Hearsay is an out-of-court statement (made orally, in writing, or through conduct by someone other than the witness currently testifying) that is offered in court to prove that the content of the statement itself is true. As a general rule, hearsay evidence is inadmissible in California court proceedings, including probate matters, because it is considered inherently less reliable than live testimony subject to cross-examination.
Exceptions in Probate: Despite the general rule, proving the intent or actions of a deceased person (like a testator or trust settlor) often relies on statements they made before death. California law provides specific exceptions to the hearsay rule that are crucial in probate and trust litigation:
- State of Mind Exception: Statements made by a deceased person concerning their own then-existing state of mind, emotion, or physical sensation—including statements about their intent, plan, motive, design, mental feeling, pain, or health—are generally admissible to prove that state of mind or condition, provided the statements were made under circumstances indicating trustworthiness (Cal. Evid. Code § 1250, § 1251). This is often used to show testamentary intent, feelings about beneficiaries, or susceptibility to undue influence.
- Statements Regarding Revocable Trusts (Evid. Code § 1260): California Evidence Code § 1260 provides a specific hearsay exception for statements made by a deceased settlor (unavailable witness). Such statements are admissible if they assert that the settlor established, amended, or revoked a revocable trust, or identify their revocable trust or its amendments, provided the statements were made under circumstances indicating trustworthiness. This allows testimony from percipient witnesses (those who heard the statements directly) about what the settlor said regarding the status or identity of their revocable trust.